Fifth Star Funds
Apply Give
Home · Portfolio · ThrowbackBuys
BuildingMarketplaceBacked 2025

ThrowbackBuys

Founded by LeMarc Johnson

An online marketplace where people buy, sell and bid on the toys, games, clothes, tapes and tech of the 1980s through Y2K, stocked by vetted independent sellers.

The founder
LeMarc Johnson, founder of ThrowbackBuys

LeMarc Johnson

"What you get when Myspace and eBay make a baby..."

LeMarc Johnson, founder
What they do

The nostalgia market is spread across generic resale sites where nothing is curated and nothing is verified. ThrowbackBuys puts it in one place, with curators who assemble Time Capsules and Top 8s and run live auctions.

Who it's for

Millennials and Gen X buying back what they grew up with, and the collectors and resellers who sell through it.

What's different

Curation, for one era, the 1980s through Y2K. It also publishes its own research on the category.


What they've done, with sources
Back a founder

Every Fifth Star company gets the same $25,000 check.

Contributions go into the fund that writes them. If ThrowbackBuys exits one day, our share comes back to the fund and goes out again, which is what makes us an evergreen fund.

More from the portfolio

Stay in touch

Updates on the founders we back and the work behind the checks.